News
December 02, 2025
Commentary: The American middle class is shrinking, and that’s OK
The good news is that Americans have never been richer. The bad news is that most of them don’t feel like it.
The American dream, traditionally built on the strength of its middle class, is undergoing a significant transformation. While anxieties swirl about the shrinking middle class, a closer look reveals a more nuanced picture: Americans, on average, have never been wealthier, even if that prosperity isn't universally felt.
The narrative of a disappearing middle class often evokes images of economic hardship and downward mobility. While it's true that the proportion of Americans identifying as middle class has decreased over the past few decades, this shift doesn't automatically translate to widespread economic suffering. Instead, some economists argue, a significant portion of those leaving the middle class are actually moving upwards into higher income brackets. This upward mobility contributes to an overall increase in national wealth, even as the traditional bell curve of income distribution flattens.
However, this good news comes with a caveat: the feeling of prosperity hasn't trickled down to everyone. Despite record levels of national wealth, many Americans still struggle with stagnant wages, rising costs of living, and increasing economic insecurity. The gains from economic growth have disproportionately benefited those at the top, leading to a widening gap between the rich and the rest.
This disparity fuels a sense of unease and frustration, even among those who might technically be considered "wealthier" than previous generations. The rising cost of housing, healthcare, and education, coupled with the burden of student loan debt, can negate the positive effects of higher incomes, leaving many feeling financially stressed and vulnerable.
Therefore, while the statistics might paint a picture of increasing national wealth and a shrinking middle class transitioning to higher income brackets, it's crucial to acknowledge the disconnect between the data and the lived experiences of many Americans. The challenge lies in ensuring that the benefits of economic growth are more broadly shared, fostering a sense of economic security and opportunity for all, regardless of their position on the income ladder. The focus should shift from simply celebrating aggregate wealth to addressing the underlying issues of income inequality and ensuring that the "American dream" remains attainable for everyone, not just a select few.
The narrative of a disappearing middle class often evokes images of economic hardship and downward mobility. While it's true that the proportion of Americans identifying as middle class has decreased over the past few decades, this shift doesn't automatically translate to widespread economic suffering. Instead, some economists argue, a significant portion of those leaving the middle class are actually moving upwards into higher income brackets. This upward mobility contributes to an overall increase in national wealth, even as the traditional bell curve of income distribution flattens.
However, this good news comes with a caveat: the feeling of prosperity hasn't trickled down to everyone. Despite record levels of national wealth, many Americans still struggle with stagnant wages, rising costs of living, and increasing economic insecurity. The gains from economic growth have disproportionately benefited those at the top, leading to a widening gap between the rich and the rest.
This disparity fuels a sense of unease and frustration, even among those who might technically be considered "wealthier" than previous generations. The rising cost of housing, healthcare, and education, coupled with the burden of student loan debt, can negate the positive effects of higher incomes, leaving many feeling financially stressed and vulnerable.
Therefore, while the statistics might paint a picture of increasing national wealth and a shrinking middle class transitioning to higher income brackets, it's crucial to acknowledge the disconnect between the data and the lived experiences of many Americans. The challenge lies in ensuring that the benefits of economic growth are more broadly shared, fostering a sense of economic security and opportunity for all, regardless of their position on the income ladder. The focus should shift from simply celebrating aggregate wealth to addressing the underlying issues of income inequality and ensuring that the "American dream" remains attainable for everyone, not just a select few.
Category:
Business